Halloween: From Samhain to the Modern Celebration: What the History Really Tells Us
Updated: Oct 26

Halloween is one of those celebrations that seems to gather many different stories around it. Ancient festivals, Christian holy days, folk customs, migration and modern popular culture have all contributed to what we now recognise on 31 October. The result is fascinating, but it also means that simple claims such as ‘Halloween is just Samhain’ leave out much of the real history.
The story also becomes more interesting when we look beyond Britain and Ireland. Halloween itself has specific historical roots, but other cultures developed their own customs around ancestors, the dead, visiting houses, food, light and remembrance. Those traditions should not be collapsed into one origin story simply because they sometimes look similar.
Halloween history: Samhain and the turning of the year
Samhain was a Gaelic seasonal festival associated with the beginning of winter. It belonged to a world in which the agricultural year, changing light and the movement from harvest into winter mattered deeply. Medieval Irish literature preserves references to Samhain as an important date, but the details of ancient practice are not complete enough for us to treat every modern Halloween custom as a direct survival from pre-Christian Ireland.
What we can say is that the season itself carried powerful themes: endings, transition, darkness, winter and the uncertain boundary between one part of the year and the next.
All Hallows’ Eve
Christian observances also shaped the date. All Saints’ Day on 1 November and All Souls’ Day on 2 November created a period focused on saints, the dead and remembrance. The evening before All Saints’ Day became All Hallows’ Eve — eventually shortened to Halloween.
Across Britain and Ireland, local customs developed around prayer, food, disguises, fires and visiting from house to house. These traditions were not identical everywhere, and they changed over centuries.
From turnips to pumpkins
Lantern carving is a good example of a custom that evolved. In Ireland and parts of Britain, people carved root vegetables such as turnips. When Irish and Scottish migrants carried traditions to North America, pumpkins were larger, softer and easier to carve. The glowing jack-o’-lantern became one of Halloween’s most recognisable images.
The older lantern tradition could be much more unsettling than the cheerful pumpkin faces we know today. A hollowed turnip, with pale flesh, narrow eyes and a candle inside, created a distinctly ghostlike appearance. Museum records from Ireland preserve examples of the type of ‘ghost turnip’ people remembered using to frighten others on Halloween night.
Halloween was once full of fortune-telling
Another part of Halloween that is often forgotten is how closely it became linked with divination, especially questions about love and marriage. Historic nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century accounts describe young people burning nuts, peeling apples, looking into mirrors and using household objects to try to discover the identity or initials of a future partner.
That gives us a very different picture from modern horror-centred Halloween. For many people, the night was playful, social and curious about the future as much as it was concerned with ghosts.
How migration transformed Halloween
Migration did not simply transport Halloween unchanged. In North America, customs from different immigrant communities mixed with local conditions, newspapers, parties, postcards and later commercial entertainment. Pumpkins replaced dense root vegetables, house-to-house visiting became increasingly organised, and Halloween gradually moved toward the community celebration recognised today.
Films, television, advertising and global retail then carried this American style of Halloween far beyond the places where its earlier customs had developed. This is why orange-and-black decorations, carved pumpkins and costume parties now appear in countries with no historical Samhain tradition at all.
The Philippines: a door-to-door tradition of wandering souls
A fascinating comparison comes from the Philippines. In parts of the country, pangangaluluwa was traditionally practised around All Saints’ and All Souls’ observances. Groups went from house to house singing as if they were wandering souls and received food or offerings in return.
At first glance, that may look surprisingly similar to trick-or-treating. But similarity does not prove a shared origin. Pangangaluluwa belongs to Filipino Catholic and local ancestral traditions and deserves to be understood on its own terms rather than labelled a local version of Halloween.
Día de los Muertos is not Mexican Halloween
The same distinction matters with Día de los Muertos. Because it is observed at the same time of year and includes skulls, candles, flowers and the dead, it is often blended into Halloween imagery outside Mexico. But it is a distinct Mexican tradition shaped by Indigenous and Catholic histories, centred on remembrance, family and the temporary return of deceased loved ones.
Keeping these traditions separate does not make the comparison less interesting. It makes it more accurate. Different cultures can use food, light, disguise or visits to the dead in very different ways without belonging to the same historical tradition.
Why Halloween still fascinates us
Modern Halloween can be playful, theatrical or deeply atmospheric. Costumes, ghost stories and lanterns give us a safe way to approach subjects that are usually kept at a distance: darkness, fear, death, change and the unknown.
For me, that is where the history becomes especially interesting. Traditions survive not because they remain frozen, but because people keep finding meaning in them. Halloween has changed many times, yet its position at the edge of winter still gives it that unmistakable feeling of standing at a threshold.
And when we look globally, the most valuable lesson is not that every culture has ‘its own Halloween’. It is that human beings everywhere have found different ways to live with the same large questions: how we face darkness, how we remember the dead, how we turn fear into story, and how we mark the moment when one season gives way to another.










Comments