
Witchcraft: The Women, the Healing Knowledge and the History Behind a Loaded Word
Updated: Oct 26

Today, the word “witchcraft” can mean many different things. It can describe a modern spiritual identity, folk practice, divination, ritual, herbal work, Wicca, protective customs or practices that an outsider simply does not understand.
Historically, however, “witch” was very often not a name a person chose for herself. It was a word placed upon her by somebody else.
It could mean that a neighbour believed she had caused illness or misfortune. It could suggest harmful magic, dealings with spirits, heresy or, later, a pact with the Devil. The meaning changed according to place, century, religion and law. That history matters because the frightening image attached to the word did not appear all at once. It was built slowly from fear, theology, social tension, gender, law and popular imagination.
witchcraft history: Before the stereotype: women as carers and keepers of practical knowledge
For much of European history, healthcare did not begin in a hospital or consulting room. It began at home, in the kitchen, beside the bed and around the birthing woman.
Women were deeply involved in everyday care. They treated family members, nursed the sick, prepared food for recovery, tended wounds and passed practical knowledge through households and communities. Some became known locally for particular skills. Others assisted women through pregnancy, labour and the dangerous days after childbirth.
Their remedies could involve plants, oils, fats, wine, water, honey, roots and other materials readily available to them. What a modern imagination might call a “potion” could simply have been an infusion, syrup, salve, poultice, medicinal drink or wash. Healing practices could also include prayer, blessings and charms because the modern boundary between medicine, religion and magic did not exist in the same way.
This does not mean that every remedy worked, nor that women possessed a secret scientific medicine lost to history. It means something more interesting: knowledge of the body and of care existed outside universities as well as inside them, and women were part of that knowledge economy.
The woman who came when labour began
Childbirth made female knowledge especially visible. For centuries, birth was principally managed by women. Midwives and female attendants worked from experience, observation and knowledge transmitted from one practitioner to another. They occupied an intimate place in community life because childbirth placed two lives at risk at once.
A midwife could know how a labour usually progressed, how to position a woman, when something appeared wrong, how to care for the newborn and how to support recovery. In some places her role extended beyond delivery into broader areas of women’s health.
But one popular modern story needs correcting. Historians do not support the simple claim that the European witch hunts were essentially a campaign to exterminate midwives or female herbal healers. Some accused women were healers or midwives. Many were not. Many healers were never accused. Accusations could grow from neighbour disputes, poverty, reputation, illness, livestock deaths, unexplained misfortune, religious tension and local conflict.
That distinction makes the history more powerful rather than less. A woman did not need to be a practising healer to become a “witch”. The label could be created by fear itself.
When knowledge becomes legitimate only if an institution recognises it
During the later Middle Ages, European universities and professional medical institutions became increasingly important in defining legitimate medicine. Formal training, licensing and membership of recognised professional groups could determine who was authorised to practise.
Women were largely excluded from the university structures through which learned medicine was increasingly credentialled. That did not mean women suddenly stopped healing. It meant that a growing distinction could be made between knowledge recognised by institutions and knowledge acquired through household experience, apprenticeship, oral transmission or local reputation.
One revealing example is Jacqueline Felicie de Almania, who was prosecuted in Paris in 1322 for practising medicine without the required licence. Testimony in her case described patients who believed she had helped them. Her story shows the tension between practical reputation and a professional system increasingly able to decide who counted as a legitimate medical practitioner.
It would still be too simple to say that men suddenly “removed women from medicine”. Women continued to work as midwives, carers and healers for centuries, and medicine itself was never one single profession. But over time, institutional authority mattered more. Knowledge that had once been accepted because a community trusted the practitioner could lose status when legitimacy depended upon credentials that women found difficult or impossible to obtain.
Then came the witch
European ideas about witchcraft changed dramatically between the later Middle Ages and the early modern period. Earlier ideas of harmful magic — often described by historians with the term maleficium — became increasingly joined to elaborate demonological theories. The witch was no longer imagined merely as someone who caused harm by occult means. In learned demonology she could be portrayed as a servant of Satan who had entered into a pact with the Devil.
This mattered because it transformed a suspected local wrong into a cosmic crime. A dead animal, a sick child or a failed harvest could now be imagined not only as misfortune but as evidence of a hidden enemy within the community.
Across the European witch persecutions, women formed the large majority of the accused — commonly estimated around four-fifths overall, although the proportion varied greatly between regions. Men were accused too. The predominance of women was therefore not absolute, but it was unmistakable.
Ideas about female weakness, sexuality, obedience and susceptibility to the Devil fed this gendered picture. So did ordinary social life. Widows, poor women, older women, women in difficult relationships with neighbours and women whose words were feared could all become vulnerable in particular circumstances. Witchcraft accusation became one of the ways a community could explain danger, resentment and uncertainty.
The historical cruelty of a word
This is where the word itself becomes important.
Calling somebody a witch could erase everything else about her. A neighbour became a danger. An old woman became a threat. A healer could become suspicious. Poverty could become evidence. A quarrel could become a curse. A bodily mark could be examined as proof. An animal near the house could become a demonic familiar.
The National Archives preserves cases in which neighbours accused one another after misfortune, as well as cases in which communities defended women who had been accused. Records also show that authorities themselves could doubt accusations. The history was never as simple as a united society hunting an easily identifiable group called “witches”.
That is precisely why the label was so powerful. It did not describe one clear profession or one consistent set of practices. It gathered fear around a person.
So where did the broom come from?
The broom is almost perfect as a symbol because it began as something profoundly ordinary. Sweeping was domestic work. The broom belonged to the household and therefore to the visual world traditionally associated with women.
By the late medieval and early modern periods, European art and folklore were developing images of witches travelling through the air on household objects, including broomsticks. The familiar flying witch was created from a mixture of folklore, demonology, artistic convention and stories about nocturnal journeys. Over time the broom became inseparable from the witch image.
There is a certain historical irony in this transformation. An object associated with domestic labour — one of the most ordinary tools in a woman’s home — became evidence, in the imagination, that she had escaped the limits of that home and could fly.
And the cat?
Cats did not become “witches’ animals” because every accused woman owned one. The connection developed through beliefs about familiars — spirits or supernatural helpers imagined in animal form — and through wider associations between certain animals, darkness, secrecy and the demonic.
English and Scottish witchcraft records contain references to spirits appearing as cats, dogs, hares and other animals. The cat eventually became the most recognisable of them in popular culture. Black cats in particular accumulated additional layers of superstition, but the historical familiar was not always a cat and certainly not always black.
The pointed hat is younger than people think
The classic tall black pointed hat is not a reliable costume of historical accused witches. Women accused of witchcraft generally wore the ordinary clothes of their place and social position.
The pointed-hat stereotype appears to have grown gradually from several strands of visual culture. Historians have connected it with styles of tall felt hats worn in the seventeenth century, representations of Quaker women, and older European images that used pointed hats to mark religious outsiders. There is no single moment at which a “witch hat” was invented.
Later illustration, theatre, Halloween culture and film simplified these varied images into the costume we recognise immediately today: black dress, pointed hat, broom and cat. Popular culture made the symbol clear by making the history less complicated.
What we call “witchcraft” today is not one historical thing
This is perhaps the most important point.
A modern person may proudly call herself a witch. She may practise Wicca, folk magic, divination, ritual, herbalism or a personal form of spirituality. That identity deserves to be understood on its own terms.
But we should not project that modern identity backwards and assume that the thousands of historical people accused of witchcraft belonged to the same kind of spiritual tradition. For many of them, “witch” was not an identity. It was an accusation that could destroy a reputation, a livelihood or a life.
Why the word still matters
The word “witchcraft” still has emotional force because centuries of meaning remain attached to it. It can suggest rebellion, female independence, danger, forbidden knowledge, nature, healing, magic, evil or empowerment depending on who is speaking.
Sometimes the word gives people a spiritual identity they actively choose. Sometimes it is still used to make unfamiliar practices sound frightening. And historically it could turn ordinary human conflict into a supernatural accusation.
Perhaps the better question is not simply, “Is this witchcraft?” but “What is the person actually doing, where does the practice come from, and what did that word mean in that time and place?”
When we ask that question, a different history appears. Behind the broom, the cat, the hat and the cauldron are real people: women caring for bodies, women assisting births, women working within households, women with knowledge, women without knowledge, women who were feared, women who were disliked, women who were vulnerable — and also men who were accused beside them.
The history of witchcraft is therefore not the history of one secret religion or one persecuted profession. It is the history of belief, medicine, gender, authority, fear and the extraordinary power of a label.










Comments